PL3 Virtual Roundtable Recap: Better Diligence - Closing the Gap Between Buyers and Sellers
Event Recording: PL3 Virtual Roundtable | Better Diligence: Closing the Gap Between Buyers and Sellers
Summary: This PL3 Virtual Roundtable examines why due diligence remains a costly and time-consuming part of lower-middle-market transactions. The discussion explores financial reporting, buyer and seller expectations, leadership readiness, organizational risk, and how better preparation and more thoughtful use of technology could improve transaction outcomes.
Roundtable Date: November 19, 2026
Due diligence is supposed to build confidence in a business transaction.
Buyers want to verify financial performance, understand potential risks, and determine whether a company represents a sound investment. Sellers want to demonstrate the value of the businesses they've spent years building and move toward a successful transaction.
Yet both sides frequently find themselves spending considerable time and resources reconciling financial information, answering questions, and navigating a process that can become increasingly expensive and complicated.
What if due diligence could become more than a transaction expense?
That question was at the center of PL3's November Virtual Roundtable, Better Diligence: Closing the Gap Between Buyers and Sellers.
Bob Dunn, Chief Product Officer at ACG, and Lindsay Guzowski, CEO of The Crucible, joined PL3 CMO William Gladhart to explore how buyers, sellers, and advisors might rethink the diligence process.
Their conversation examined not only the financial information required to complete a transaction but also the leadership, organizational capabilities, and strategic opportunities that can influence what happens after the sale.
The Financial Disconnect Between Buyers and Sellers
Technology has transformed how financial information is collected and shared, but the diligence process itself hasn't necessarily evolved at the same pace.
Dunn explained that many smaller middle-market businesses lack integrated financial reporting systems...information may be spread across accounting platforms, spreadsheets, sales records, and other disconnected sources.
Although physical data rooms have largely been replaced by virtual platforms, buyers and sellers still spend substantial time organizing, interpreting, and reconciling the same underlying information.
Guzowski highlighted another challenge: business owners and buyers often approach financial information from entirely different perspectives.
Owners use financial information to manage their businesses, monitor cash flow, and make operational decisions. Buyers need that same information organized to support valuation, risk assessment, and investment decisions.
The numbers may be accurate, but they aren't always presented in a way that buyers can readily evaluate.
Dunn emphasized the importance of preparing a consistent three-year financial history, including appropriate adjusted EBITDA calculations, so buyers can better understand the business from an investment perspective.
The objective isn't to eliminate independent verification...it's to reduce the unnecessary work required to understand the information being presented.
Preparing a Business for the Buyer's Perspective
One of the recurring themes was the importance of owners recognizing how their businesses may look to someone evaluating them for the first time.
Dunn noted that owners often become accustomed to challenges they've lived with for years - those same issues may be immediately apparent to a prospective buyer.
“The problems that you live with as an owner...you live with those issues long enough and it just kind of looks normal.”
Recognizing and addressing those challenges before going to market can help reduce uncertainty during diligence.
Guzowski reinforced the importance of transparency. “It's intellectual honesty about what you're doing and what you're not doing.”
Business owners make decisions based on available capital, staffing, resources, and market conditions. They may defer investments, pursue certain customers, or leave growth opportunities unexplored.
Those decisions aren't necessarily weaknesses. What matters is whether the owner understands the implications and can explain the reasoning behind them.
A business doesn't have to be perfect to attract a buyer, but surprises discovered during diligence can undermine confidence and raise questions about what else may not be understood.
For owners who may sell a business only once in their lifetime, experienced M&A advisors and financial professionals can provide valuable perspective on what buyers expect and how to prepare.
Beyond Financial Diligence: Leadership, Culture, and Organizational Readiness
Financial performance remains fundamental, but buyers are also evaluating the people and capabilities responsible for producing those results.
Guzowski discussed the importance of understanding leadership-team cohesion, individual capabilities, and whether key executives are prepared to support the organization following an acquisition.
These considerations become especially important when buyers expect to accelerate growth or introduce new operating requirements.
Dunn raised another significant issue for smaller businesses: owner dependency.
Founders frequently serve multiple roles, including CEO, primary salesperson, customer relationship manager or technology leader.
That involvement may contribute to the company's success under current ownership, but it can also create transition risks.
Who assumes those responsibilities when the owner steps away?
And does the business have the leadership capacity to operate successfully without the founder's daily involvement?
Guzowski also emphasized that a transaction needs to make sense beyond the financial terms. The expectations of the buyer, the capabilities of the leadership team, and the future role of the seller can all influence whether the acquisition succeeds.
Diligence, therefore, isn't simply about verifying what a company has accomplished, it's also about understanding whether the organization can succeed under new ownership.
Turning Diligence Into an Opportunity for Value Creation
What if diligence helped buyers and sellers identify future opportunities rather than simply uncover existing risks?
Both panelists explored how the process could provide greater insight into the potential value of a business.
Guzowski emphasized the importance of identifying the opportunities a buyer intends to pursue: “It's understanding and laying out what are the value levers that are expected from the buyer.”
That includes evaluating the leadership team's capabilities and determining what additional resources may be needed to support growth.
These conversations can create a stronger foundation for the transition following an acquisition. Understanding the people, priorities, and opportunities before closing can make the first 100 days substantially more productive.
Dunn noted that owners frequently recognize growth opportunities they haven't pursued because they lacked the capital, time, or resources...those opportunities may become more achievable under new ownership.
However, buyers need more than optimistic projections.
Dunn emphasized the importance of supporting potential growth opportunities with credible forecasts, clear assumptions, and an explanation of why those opportunities haven't already been pursued.
Without that supporting information, prospective growth can appear speculative. Better diligence could help distinguish realistic opportunities from assumptions while giving both parties greater confidence in the business's future potential.
The AI Paradox: More Information Doesn't Always Mean Better Diligence
Artificial intelligence has introduced new opportunities to accelerate financial analysis, review contracts, organize information, and identify potential issues.
But the panelists also cautioned that technology can create additional friction when used without sufficient judgment.
Dunn described how AI tools can generate extensive lists of diligence questions, including issues that may have little relevance to the actual transaction. “
"We now have the opportunity to question everything via AI, and I think that drags down the process.”
Instead of improving efficiency, excessive questioning can increase costs, prolong the process, and create unnecessary tension between buyers and sellers. His advice was to maintain a strategic perspective and concentrate on the questions that genuinely matter.
Financial confidence, management capabilities, and the business's strategic direction deserve careful examination. Not every conceivable question requires the same level of attention.
Guzowski reinforced the importance of retaining human judgment as technology becomes more accessible..."Use AI to facilitate your thinking, not do the thinking for you."
Her advice was to use AI tools in a way that supports thoughtful analysis rather than allowing them to substitute for it.
The distinction is important.
Technology can help professionals identify issues and process information more efficiently. But determining which findings matter, how they relate to the business, and what they mean for a transaction still requires experience and critical thinking.
Better Information, Better Questions, Better Outcomes
The November Roundtable reinforced that improving due diligence requires more than better technology or more comprehensive financial reporting.
Owners need to understand how buyers will evaluate their businesses, prepare credible information, acknowledge challenges, and consider the leadership and organizational capabilities required for a successful transition.
Buyers and advisors need to distinguish between questions that genuinely improve transaction confidence and those that add complexity without creating meaningful value.
And both sides have an opportunity to approach diligence as more than a process for validating historical performance - it can also provide a foundation for understanding future opportunities, aligning expectations, and preparing the business for what comes next.
Better diligence doesn't eliminate risk or remove the need for independent verification.
Instead, it creates an opportunity to reduce unnecessary friction, improve transparency, and make more informed decisions.
For business owners, buyers, and advisors navigating the lower-middle market, that shift could help turn due diligence from a necessary transaction expense into a more valuable part of building a successful outcome.
Will Gladhart is Chief Marketing Officer at PL3, where he leads brand strategy, content creation, and communications.



Comments